Sixteen worker-browser proofs still opened the removed History tabs,
clicked the removed Refresh button or depended on UI that has since
moved. Each now passes on pulse-dev:
- Charts are read on Overview (guest, resource, PBS) or inline in disk
and pool details; table-row-touch toggles Manage/Overview as its
nested input instead of the old tab.
- Reads are driven through the 30-second poll with the page clock.
- Locators select series paths and hover markers, since bands and
observation dots also draw paths.
- Rows lifted into Worth checking or kept under the closed Details
disclosure are read from the whole Overview, with Details opened.
- With stored history shown, the legend reads the latest stored time,
so series without a point say "no reading" rather than a live value.
- Stubbed history replies echo the requested series and carry min/max,
as the client has validated since 866da85c26.
- Fixtures that mount the resource drawer supply activeAlerts.
- The guest-stopped-disk write check allows the content-free
workload-history usage milestone that opening details records.
- On emulated phones, headless Chromium reports a fine pointer, so the
proof touches the plot before tapping the inspection slider.
The drawer tab-retention proof (#1723) and the PBS host history
correlation proof share browser-tests/pbs-host-history-correlation.tsx.
That fixture mounted the Backups table without the app runtime context
the drawer Overview reads alerts from, so both proofs threw before the
drawer rendered and had silently stopped proving anything.
The fixture now supplies an explicit offline WebSocket and dark-mode
context and a router, as the other drawer fixtures do. The correlation
proof follows the drawer's current shape: history charts sit on
Overview, so it checks that Overview stays selected with stable chart
paths across refreshes. Since the Identity card shows each identifier
once, the Metrics Target row may be absent; when present it must name
the host series, and the intercepted history request still must.
Both proofs pass at 1280 and 390px on every topology. Negative controls
fail as they should: resetting the tab when the metrics target drops
breaks the retention proof, and charting the PBS service key breaks the
correlation proof.
Beta cut from main at 1844f6c0ed. It carries every change merged since stable v6.5.0.
Contract-Neutral: Release-only v6.6.0-beta.3 version, release notes and distribution metadata; no public install or runtime contract changes.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The beta release train writes cumulative changelogs from the previous
stable, but the install packet check required the previous numbered
beta. Accept both supported comparison modes and continue rejecting
unrelated, missing or ambiguous bases.
Validation: targeted race tests and the failed beta.3 snapshot
regression, plus governance audits and native commit and push checks.
The release train explicitly compares the full beta range with the previous stable. Accept that supported base as well as the default previous numbered prerelease, while rejecting missing, ambiguous and unrelated comparison bases.
Contract-Neutral: Align release packet checks with the existing metadata contract. No public install or runtime contract delta.
PR 2913 moved the Proxmox guest and node drawers' charts onto Overview
and removed their History tab. The Docker host drawer and the shared
resource-detail drawer (agent machines, containers, PBS, TrueNAS,
Kubernetes and other platform rows) still kept the charts a tab away,
so the same kind of drawer behaved two ways depending on the page.
Both now render the history charts on Overview under the attention
list, opening on 24 hours with the range picker beside them, and drop
the History tab. Charts stop polling while another tab shows, and an
active alert on a charted metric draws its trigger the same way as in
the Proxmox drawers. A resource whose metrics target drops for one
snapshot simply loses its charts until the target returns; the
selected tab is kept.
Storage page disk and pool details keep their own History tab; they
are separate components and their Overview has no charts to repeat.
E2E specs 27 and 63 no longer click History; the drawer read starts
when it opens. The manual tab-retention proof now selects Manage. Its
fixture page fails before the drawer renders (no WebSocket provider)
on main as well, so it was not run.
The Workloads table put a second line under memory and disk cells on
every stopped guest ("N/A / Unavailable", "- / Unavailable"), on every
agentless VM's disk, and "May include cache" under every agentless VM's
memory bar, even at 20%. None of them said why or what to do, and they
broke the row rhythm.
Memory that cannot be read now renders the same dash as an unreadable
disk, with its reason in the cell title, the sparkline's hover title
and assistive text. Disk shows a visible label only for a retained
reading (Last known) or a read the user can fix (No permission, Agent
error). The cache caption appears only when the guest's own memory is
at its warning or critical threshold, the figure that colours the bar
in host-share mode too, which is the case #2762 and #2639 were about;
below that the caveat stays in the title and assistive text.
An unavailable memory explanation names what is known instead of
"Unknown source": a powered-off guest reads "Unavailable while the
guest is powered off." MetricMiniSparkline gains an optional tooltip
so the chart covering the cell can carry that reason without changing
its accessible name.
Governance now reports explicit completion, residuals, evidence and
ownership availability. It no longer computes lane grades, completion
percentages or weighted candidate priority. Release qualification,
security assertions and lease boundaries stay enforced.
The frontend contract also drops obsolete Discovery surface catalogs and
preserves the live Assistant handoff and execution contracts.
Validation: 93 focused Python tests, repository-control Go tests, and
control-plane, status, registry and contract audits. Full delivery hooks
passed, including 164 helper tests and frontend audits after integration
with current main.
The first beta's page listed no changes, and the full changelog file is
neither attached to nor linked from any release page, so a reader could
not look up a change the summary did not name. Add a pointer, advisory
and additive.
The renderer appends a "## Source comparison" section after Roll back: a
link to GitHub's comparison of the release tag with the stable rollback
target the workflow already passes (--rollback-target and --candidate-tag).
It is a pointer, not a list. GitHub shows at most 250 commits in a
comparison and this beta had 328 changes, so the section says larger
comparisons may omit commits and is not called a full list.
It never fails a release on its own. The helper renders nothing, and
raises nothing, for a missing or malformed tag, a base that is not a
lower stable release, a trailing newline, non-ASCII digits, or numbers
too large to convert. Bodies without the section, including every
earlier release and any frozen in-flight one, keep validating, because
the validator already permits a trailing section and is unchanged. The
post-update changelog dialog reads only recognised category headings, so
a separate heading after Roll back is ignored by it.
Every consumer of the rendered body was audited (the renderer's
validators, create-release, validate-release-assets,
recover-release-activation, the updater backend, the what's-new model and
the Go and TypeScript tests): no regression. Review of the first draft
found a crash on a 5000-digit tag, a newline that would land inside the
URL, and overclaiming contract text; all fixed and pinned by tests that
fail against the first draft. A tags/ prefix would avoid a branch that
shares a tag's name, but GitHub's web comparison URL returned 404 for it
on existing tags, so bare refs are used and the limit is recorded.
Tests run the real renderer on the v6.5.0 notes: placement after Roll
back, exact spacing, numeric ordering, ten edit and annotation cycles
with CRLF and the extra jq newline, expected-body rejection of a changed
or deleted section, and absence still validating. They fail against the
original renderer. Making the section required, and a generated
row-level inventory that proves completeness, need a declarative contract
record in the preparation snapshot and are deliberately deferred; the
contract explains why.
Contract-Neutral: Adds an advisory link to rendered release pages; no published artifact, tag, signing, install or customer contract changes.
Preserve current Patrol setup and provider connection behavior alongside
the explicit governance completion and evidence contract. Inherited
application states retain their qualified main content.
A Proxmox node move changed the workload row key, reset an open drawer’s
History view and could publish new coordinates before saved guest
metadata migrated. Rows now use the stable unified resource ID,
bookmarks resolve through the registry, and the selected resource owns
its drawer tab and History range across regrouping.
Accepted publication migrates metadata before exposing the new node. A
failed write retains operator fields in memory and the last successful
disk snapshot, with recovery through the existing writer. Native
metadata and History coordinates remain separate from row identity.
Backend metrics targets take precedence over the legacy native fallback.
Route focus owns initial positioning. Viewport initialization measures
the selected row without replacing its reveal window. Local row clicks
retain their scroll position, while later scroll and resize events
follow the viewport. Operator policy, Assistant, all four Patrol modes
and paid entitlements are preserved.
The proof registry owns the focused publication and writer tests. Its
guard verifies acceptance and rejection without duplicating the catalog.
Canonical and browser guards share exact Git inheritance reads, so
updating a branch retains parent qualification for unchanged content.
New resolutions and mode changes still need current proof, and range
checks qualify the complete proposed change.
Validation:
- Regression controls reproduce publication ordering and persistence
failures. Targeted backend and race tests pass.
- Final repair checks pass: 476 tests across 15 frontend files,
type-check, production frontend build and embedded build.
- Current-source browser checks on /proxmox/overview at 1280x800,
900x800 and 390x844 cover VM and LXC, canonical and legacy links, node
regrouping, native and explicit History targets, saved links, reload,
keyboard selection, Collapse, Escape and search reselection.
- Additional desktop and phone checks cover operator policy persistence,
metadata write failure, delayed lookup cancellation and refused
references. The final browser matrix passes 196 checks.
- Merge-qualification regression reproduces inherited additions, renames
and deletions being misclassified. All 216 focused guard tests pass,
including retained mode changes, new resolutions and ordinary commits.
Browser node movement uses controlled resource updates. Publication and
metadata ordering are verified independently with filesystem barriers
and failure injection.
Refs #1669
The script-smoke fixture includes the shared repository I/O dependency.
All 23 prepush fixture tests pass.
Numeric lane grades and weighted candidate rankings duplicate model
judgment without adding a qualification invariant. Keep explicit completion,
residuals, evidence, assertions and ownership availability as the current
state contract. Remove duplicated prose catalogs and stale retired-surface
obligations while retaining their canonical owners.
The browser gate now uses the shared repository I/O module. Exercise its
real dependency in the prepush fixture so smoke tests reach qualification
checks instead of failing during import.
Contract-Neutral: Test fixture dependency only, no application or contract behavior changes.
Keep the current clock and stored-History readout alongside canonical row
selection and resource-owned drawer state.
Use one Git inheritance reader for browser and canonical qualification.
Inherited modes and objects keep their parent proof, while new resolutions
and mode changes remain subject to current contract and proof requirements.
Range checks still qualify the complete proposed change.
Refs #1669
18 of 60 paid installs on the current telemetry schema have no AI
provider. Getting Patrol running meant three pages: turn on Pulse
Intelligence, pick one of 14 providers and paste a key, choose a model
from a raw list, then find Check Patrol model on another page.
When Patrol is blocked because no provider is connected, Pulse
Intelligence is off, or the provider refused the saved key, the setup
card now connects a provider in place. It covers a cloud API key
(Anthropic, OpenAI, Gemini, DeepSeek, OpenRouter) or Ollama, names the
model Pulse will use from the Patrol guidance table, prices it before
anything is saved, then saves it, runs the provider test and the Patrol
model check, and offers the first run. A per-token model on the
untouched 6-hour schedule gets the same slower schedule Patrol settings
would propose. Everything else stays on Provider & Models.
The panel stays mounted once started, because polling flips the
readiness cause mid-setup and would otherwise remove the verdict. A
refused key (provider_auth) now routes to Provider & Models instead of
the model check, which could not fix it.
Use unified resource IDs for workload rows and selection so moving a guest
between Proxmox nodes retains its open drawer and History range. Resolve
existing bookmarks through the registry instead of rebuilding client IDs.
Migrate guest metadata before accepted inventory publication and retain its
operator fields in memory if persistence fails. Native metadata and metrics
coordinates remain explicit compatibility inputs. Operator policy and paid
execution behavior remain intact.
Register the focused publication and writer proofs once. Check proof
acceptance and rejection without copying the registry catalog into tests.
Refs #1669
A missing SCRIPT path or empty COMMAND target cannot establish that a task is unrelated or absent. Retain recovery before any task or service mutation when those fields are unavailable. Add three actual-caller adverse controls to the mandatory sixteen-method hook and both owning contracts.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Disable and independently verify every exact owned middleware activation task before systemd stop and server removal. Close task, unit and process state after the full stop and after task deletion, retaining recovery on refusals or concurrent changes without restarting. Ordinary Linux state directories are not appliance identity. Register all fifteen actual-function/full-caller controls and update both owning contracts in this coherent candidate.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The first beta's release workflow failed twice in backend_tests:
TestHostAgentCredentialFileHandoff, added on 2026-10-11 and so new to
every release job, compiles pulse-agent itself and was killed at exactly
180s with "build agent from this source: signal: killed".
The release runner starts each API shard with a small pinned GOMAXPROCS,
and the test's child compiler inherits it. A cold agent build is about
250 CPU-seconds, so under the pin it serializes past the test's fixed
three-minute limit. The release job also has no Go build cache, and the
race-enabled test binary the runner compiles does not warm this plain
build. Pull request jobs keep a warm cache, which is why the test passed
there.
Reproduced on pulse-dev with the shard's conditions, a prebuilt test
binary, GOMAXPROCS=1 and an empty cache: the test fails at 180.02s with
the identical message. With the agent built once beforehand, unpinned, in
99s, the same pinned run passes in 16s.
Build the agent once in the runner, after compiling the test binary and
before any shard starts, with the full CPU count. The runner test pins
that order so the warm-up cannot drift after the shards, and the contract
records why. Against the previous runner the pin fails with the expected
message. The release preflight and policy suites pass.
Contract-Neutral: Release test runner ordering only; no published artifact, tag, signing, install or customer contract changes.
## What changed and why
Keep Proxmox guest readings, alerts and History owned by the live
connection that collected them. A completed obsolete poll must not
republish after connection replacement, retirement or runtime shutdown.
Both enumeration routes now stage the complete guest generation and its
effects before publication. Caller detail-budget expiry still preserves
already collected inventory, without granting another read or fallback.
Make FreeBSD rc.d and SysV agent removal retain recovery material until
shutdown, process absence and disabled boot activation are confirmed.
Refused, incomplete or ambiguous observations stop removal; a partially
stopped installation is not automatically restarted. Existing
systemd/OpenRC protections remain.
Keep the guest memory explanation's agent-setup advice safe: defer
setup, restarts and live guest-agent probes during backups or an
incident. The underlying percentage, source and reading age are
unchanged.
These are bounded maintenance steps for reported workload safety,
restart recovery and safe removal, not whole-report completion. Related
to #1099, #2439, #2619, #2762 and #2822. Native recovery, independent
thaw, Windows removal and installed acceptance remain separate.
## Included source
Complete unpublished range:
`dba4b722af3f1e9a648b09ace9484a1cfc26f785..d4e89c1a1bd7892b3fc16441365a90a15139efd4`.
- Guest publication candidate:
`1ccc3651fdd611a1d5da47c5d44659fbcd4c2773` through
`08a7eaf70d8452c223e05b19ce2bd7866bbb237d`, integrated at
`ac00b9ec782b1a5964c3a9b00cdd19775293d6fc`.
- Recovery-preserving removal candidate:
`bad484550830d19569e0332c96c495e71c1694d6` through
`65f813c49758c663380ad0179e5cce3245615baf`, integrated at
`7bda196005275cd25da63776db8eadc500c0066d`.
- Memory setup precaution: `c776990b817b6a96d02abc38692960c2be578419`
and compatibility-fixture correction
`9327bc02409ffe3f07d14b8f560d6fb75d492f46`, integrated at starting
reviewed tip `020a7be6bf2a2923c291395a8409ed79ddcde336`.
- Additive upstream composition
`b523c0b6f33b6cc0ddcb36b967b05fffa7f63b4a` contains the published backup
guide unchanged. It has the same source tree as the starting reviewed
tip. Every accepted commit identity and ancestry is preserved.
- Additive correction `6281d6e0008aec029b5cc7f79820ed46159aa17a`
reconciles the canonical Docker-ingest source guard with both routes
through the ownership gate, retaining the canonical state-update
assertion and all behavioral withdrawal controls. It changes no runtime
source.
- Additive upstream composition
`a61f14c823be5ee99f20b2aa2eb3808eff83645d` incorporates the published
second-beta metadata-test repair at
`171f003a04950b53e577019398961758eb32d91c`. Its exact object was already
present; no transport or history rewrite was needed.
- Final additive composition `d4e89c1a1bd7892b3fc16441365a90a15139efd4`
incorporates published beta.2 metadata at
`dba4b722af3f1e9a648b09ace9484a1cfc26f785`. The bounded upstream refresh
completed at the requested identity with source unchanged before this
merge. It adds no new maintenance scope or release action.
## Validation and limits
Publication provenance, whitespace and all fifteen per-commit completion
guards pass. The complete-range browser guard validates the unchanged
source-bound memory precaution receipt. Recorded candidate evidence
includes 33 guest scenarios and both original 500-guest budget controls,
60 removal methods and ten targeted installer fixtures, and 40 grouped
browser checks with twelve captures recorded as inspected. Unchanged
sufficient browser evidence was not replayed merely for batching.
Earlier Go 1.26.8 results remain diagnostic rather than matching the
declared compiler.
- `source-ji6j004_` on the first composition observed Go 1.26.9 and
failed the stale direct-publication assertion. The complete failure
remains retained; later vet/installer steps were not reached.
- Corrected `source-krkur1bl` on
`6281d6e0008aec029b5cc7f79820ed46159aa17a` passes the targeted
Proxmox/guest-ownership race suite, monitoring vet, shell syntax and
twelve targeted installer/consumer tests, including fifty Python removal
controls executed through their production-function wrappers. It uses Go
1.26.9, exits zero, collects complete output and confirms guest stop.
These monitoring and agent-removal bytes are unchanged in the final
composition.
- `source-9u5ig0nx` passes 62 frontend tests, full types, changed-source
formatting/ESLint, the production/embed build and every bundle budget.
Exit zero, complete output and guest stop are recorded. The final
frontend delta from that proof is only the already-published
upgrade-guide mirror; JavaScript, styles, manifests and browser-verified
inputs are unchanged.
- `source-p3ht5oy2` verifies the reconciled canonical ingest guard and
the newly published prerelease-predecessor helper/current prerelease
metadata on `a61f14c823be5ee99f20b2aa2eb3808eff83645d`. Two
stable-packet checks correctly skip on prerelease source. Go 1.26.9,
zero exit, complete output and guest stop are recorded. The later beta.2
metadata is validated separately on the final tip.
- Exact final `source-sl4t8d7o` on
`d4e89c1a1bd7892b3fc16441365a90a15139efd4` passes shell syntax and the
prerelease-predecessor/current beta.2 install-metadata checks on Go
1.26.9. The two stable-packet checks remain explicitly skipped. Exit
zero, complete 1,485-byte output and completed guest stop are recorded.
Earlier receipts retain their reporting-line-bound flags without loss of
their complete raw output.
These checks do not establish installed restoration, native guest
safety, Docker qualification, release readiness or publication of this
maintenance. Administrative review and all required exact-head hosted
checks still govern landing; any advisory failures need an
evidence-based disposition.
[How Pulse handles
triage](https://github.com/rcourtman/Pulse/blob/main/docs/AI_TRANSPARENCY.md)
Inline and command-double changes did not establish cleanup on the retained race refusal. Register only the non-credential manual temporary with the existing installer trap and execute that exact trap in the confined caller controls. Never register the credential-bearing staged job backup for automatic deletion. All retention, no-clobber, refusal and native obligations remain intact.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The retained race refusals still left manual temporary files after the command-double change. Check write, permission and atomic link operations individually rather than relying on the grouped chain to reach cleanup. Keep concurrent files/directories and all credentials intact; the same mandatory race assertions remain. Matching Go1.26.9 is now actually observed and the complete installer suite remains required.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The two race controls retained private manual temporary files because the command double exited before the production failure handler. Exact confined traces show that exit boundary. Capture and return the real external ln exit explicitly, preserving production cleanup and every file/directory race assertion. No product code, safety assertion, method count or deadline changes.
Contract-Neutral: Faithful closed-model external exit observation only; no runtime or contract delta.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Reverts #2863 before any release ships it. No tag contains it;
v6.6.0-beta.1 predates it.
The live Pro pricing and Patrol pages, in English, German and Spanish,
sell both modes: Pro "applies safe fixes in the mode you choose (Ask
first, Safe auto-fix, or Autopilot)". Paying installs also chose them.
Shipping the retirement would have silently downgraded those installs
while the sales page still promised the modes. If the modes are retired,
that needs a dated notice: stop selling them, warn affected installs
in-app, then re-ship the change.
The companion enterprise revert (rcourtman/pulse-enterprise#114) already
landed. It is safe with either core.
The receipt #2863 landed stays in place; this adds a receipt for the
restored content.
Verification:
- Go vet is clean. config, ai, ai/qualification, telemetry,
actionlifecycle, unifiedresources, aicontracts, pkg/server and api pass
on pulse-dev. The only api failure, the server-info development check,
needs `.git` in the tree.
- Release_control Python suites, the commit guard, the status and
registry audits, and the docs mirror all pass.
- Browser, on a pulse-enterprise build of this revert with a Pro
licence:
- all four Patrol modes are offered and Safe auto-fix saves;
- the Autopilot acknowledgement dialog activates effective `full`, and
Revoke is shown;
- drawer and plan page render, and phone width is fine.
The retained fourth proof stopped at a test-double argument refusal before the intended prior-source race. Execute both legitimate ln argv forms unchanged inside the private fixture; current file/directory preservation still requires exact-target non-clobbering semantics. No product change, safety assertion, method count or deadline is weakened.
Contract-Neutral: Transparent closed-model command arguments only; no runtime or contract delta.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Extend the existing no-clobber method with file and directory creation at restoration, not only before its initial path check. The real private-file operations must retain the original staged inode and every credential, never overwrite or write inside a concurrent target. Product code, method count, deadlines and native obligations are unchanged.
Contract-Neutral: Closed-model race coverage only; no runtime or contract delta.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Reverts #2863 before any release ships it. The live Pro pricing and
Patrol pages, in English, German and Spanish, sell both modes ("applies
safe fixes in the mode you choose: Ask first, Safe auto-fix, or
Autopilot"), and paying installs chose them. Shipping the retirement
would have silently downgraded those installs while the sales page still
promised the modes.
If the modes are retired, that needs a dated notice: stop selling them
first, warn installs on those modes in-app, and then re-ship the change.
It should not arrive through an engineering cleanup.
The receipt #2863 landed stays in place; this commit adds the receipt
for the restored content.
A pathname absence check followed by mv could overwrite a concurrent root-created job. Use exact-target non-replacement links for override creation and config restoration; directory races also refuse without creating nested artifacts. Confined concurrent-file/directory controls are mandatory. Partial activation is never restarted and conflicting staged recovery is never discarded.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Beta cut from main at 171f003a04. It carries every change merged since stable v6.5.0.
Contract-Neutral: Release-only v6.6.0-beta.2 version, release notes and distribution metadata; no public install or runtime contract changes.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The first exact proof retained two fixture failures: timeout executes an external initctl rather than a shell function, and the source-order assertion unintentionally included later install code. Remove the actual model binary for its missing-tool control and bound the assertion to uninstall. Add an explicit concurrent-config/no-clobber recovery verdict; product code and safety deadlines are unchanged.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Treat DSM6 Upstart and stale DSM7 jobs through their actual manager, not SysV or late best-effort cleanup. Keep trusted job state and credentials on refused, unknown or partial observations; require effective manual activation and observed stopped/absent processes before remote removal and local erasure. Stage the original config until absence is confirmed, restore without restart on failure, and preserve non-clobbering recovery. Mandatory production-function/caller controls retain every refusal and timeout boundary. This is confined source repair, not native Linux/Windows or whole-issue acceptance.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The second beta's preparation pull request failed Backend tests
(TestCurrentPrereleasePacketTracksInstallMetadata): the changelog the
release metadata tool wrote said it describes the changes since
v6.6.0-beta.1, and the test expected v6.5.0. previousPrereleaseVersion
only understood -rc.N, so for beta.2 it reported no predecessor and the
test fell back to the previous stable. The tool names the predecessor in
the pre-release's own stage, alpha, beta or rc, N-1.
Do the same in the helper: rc.2 follows rc.1 and beta.2 follows beta.1,
while the first of a stage has no predecessor even when an earlier stage
shipped. Pin it with a table test, because beta.1 passed without ever
exercising the second-beta case.
Run against the beta.2 preparation snapshot with this change, the whole
installer test package and the release policy suite pass.
Contract-Neutral: Test helper only; no release, install or customer contract changes.
The first beta's release workflow failed in publish_docker at "Verify
exact tags and signed provenance": gh attestation verify copied an image
blob from Docker Hub and got a 502 Bad Gateway. The verifier calls
docker buildx imagetools inspect and gh attestation verify against
Docker Hub and GHCR with no tolerance for a transient registry error, so
one 5xx fails the whole release, and the train can rerun it only once.
Each of those reads is now retried up to four times with doubling
backoff from 10 seconds. They are idempotent, and a moved tag or an
invalid attestation fails identically on every attempt, so a real
failure is delayed by the backoff and never masked. The script's stdout
is the step output, so each attempt's stdout is captured and only the
successful attempt's is emitted: a failed read that printed half a
manifest cannot corrupt the verified digests. VERIFY_REGISTRY_ATTEMPTS
and VERIFY_REGISTRY_WAIT_SECONDS tune it, validated as small whole
numbers so the retry stays bounded.
Tests use doubles that fail like a dropped connection: transient
attestation reads are retried and only the digest proof is emitted; a
digest read that prints a partial manifest before failing leaves no
trace in the output; an exhausted attempt budget fails with an explicit
error and no output; unbounded settings are rejected. The old assertion
that an unverifiable attestation costs exactly one read now expects the
four attempts. Against the previous script the new tests fail. The
contract records the retry.
Checked: all 9 tests in the verifier's test file pass; the script and
its test are not registered in a subsystem, so the completion guard has
no proof file to require.
Second of the release-path retries after #2862 (release listing 504).
Patrol now has two modes: **Watch only** reports findings, and **Ask
first** investigates and proposes fixes. Every fix waits in Actions for
an operator to approve and run it. Safe auto-fix (`assisted`) and
Autopilot (`full`) are retired.
Why: schema-v17 telemetry for the week to 2026-10-11 counts 1 assisted
and 2 full installs out of 612 reporting Patrol, and 4 executed Patrol
actions in 30 days, all on one install. No GitHub issue asks for more
autonomy. Meanwhile the automatic path carried its own policy leases,
acknowledgement store, per-resource allowlist, release gate and Colima
lab. Investigation is what paid installs use, so it stays.
Behaviour
- A saved `assisted`, `full` or `autonomous` level reads as `approval`.
Both autonomy update routes refuse those levels with `400
invalid_autonomy_level`. The acknowledgement routes are gone.
- The core Patrol action broker only plans: `Plan` and `Submit` persist
the plan and return. `TestContract_PatrolActionBrokerOnlyPlans` forbids
execution calls in its source.
- Removed:
- `ExecuteUnderPolicy`, the policy authorization lease, and the policy
execution store methods;
- Autopilot acknowledgement persistence, its routes and its dialog;
- the per-resource automatic-action allowlist: type, API field and
drawer editor. The store column is written as NULL.
- Kept for compatibility:
- `GetPatrolFullModeUnlocked` stays on the extension contract and
reports false;
- historical action records keep their lease and reason codes decodable,
labelled as retired modes.
- The Patrol inbox no longer has a "continuing without a decision"
bucket: every current issue is an operator decision.
Governance
- RG-06 now proves Patrol never executes without an operator decision
(integration tier).
- RG-02/RG-04 and the RA35/RA39/RA40 proof commands point at surviving
tests. Every `-run` name was checked against `git grep '^func Test'`.
- Pro plan copy, AI docs, privacy telemetry wording and the subsystem
contracts describe the two modes.
Verification
- Go: vet is clean. config, ai, ai/qualification, telemetry,
actionlifecycle, unifiedresources, aicontracts and api pass on
pulse-dev.
- Frontend: type-check and lint are clean; 217 related test files pass.
- Governance: release_control Python suites, status/registry audits and
the docs mirror pass.
- Browser: a pulse-enterprise build of this tree with a Pro licence, run
before and after merging onto main:
- the Patrol selector has exactly two modes, and each save reads back;
- retired levels get 400, and the acknowledgement route returns 404;
- the drawer Manage tab has no allowlist editor and still saves;
- phone width is fine; the plan page shows no retired modes.
The first beta's release workflow failed in publish_docker at "Verify
exact tags and signed provenance": gh attestation verify copied an image
blob from Docker Hub and got a 502 Bad Gateway. The verifier calls
docker buildx imagetools inspect and gh attestation verify against
Docker Hub and GHCR with no tolerance for a transient registry error, so
one 5xx fails the whole release, and the train can rerun it only once.
Retry each of those reads up to four times with doubling backoff from 10
seconds. They are idempotent, and a moved tag or an invalid attestation
fails identically on every attempt, so a real failure is delayed by the
backoff and never masked. This script's stdout is the step output, so
each attempt's stdout is captured and only the successful attempt's is
emitted: a failed read that printed half a manifest cannot corrupt the
verified digests. VERIFY_REGISTRY_ATTEMPTS and VERIFY_REGISTRY_WAIT_SECONDS
tune it, validated as small whole numbers so the retry stays bounded.
Test it with doubles that fail like a dropped connection: transient
attestation reads are retried and only the digest proof is emitted; a
digest read that prints a partial manifest before failing leaves no trace
in the output; and an exhausted attempt budget fails with an explicit
error and no output. The old assertion that an unverifiable attestation
costs exactly one read now expects the four attempts. Against the previous
script the new tests fail. The contract records the retry.
Contract-Neutral: Release verification reliability only; no published artifact, tag, signing, install or customer contract changes.
The compound worktree commands still assume pulse/v6 and reserve a lease
in the source checkout that Git does not transfer to the new worktree.
They also use a second claim implementation with different renewal and
expiry rules. No callers remain outside their entrypoints, docs and tests.
Use ordinary Git tools under the current branch policy and the supported
work_claim command in the checkout where the slice runs. Remove the legacy
workflow, its private claim engine and their obsolete advertisements.
Patrol could run some fixes on its own in two paid modes: assisted (Safe
auto-fix) and full (Autopilot, behind a server-owned acknowledgement).
Schema-v17 telemetry for the week to 2026-10-11 counts 1 assisted and 2
full installs out of 612 reporting Patrol, 4 executed Patrol actions in
30 days, all on one install, and no GitHub request for more autonomy,
while the automatic path carried its own policy leases, acknowledgement
store, per-resource allowlist, release gate and Colima lab. Investigation
is what paid installs use, so it stays.
Patrol now has two modes. Watch only reports findings. Ask first
investigates and proposes fixes, and every fix waits in Actions for an
operator to approve and run it.
- A saved assisted, full or autonomous level reads as approval, and the
update routes refuse those levels with 400 invalid_autonomy_level.
- The core Patrol action broker only plans: Plan and Submit persist the
plan and return. ExecuteUnderPolicy, the policy authorization lease,
the policy admission store methods, the Autopilot acknowledgement
persistence, routes and dialog, and the per-resource automatic-action
allowlist (store column now written as NULL) are gone.
GetPatrolFullModeUnlocked stays on the extension contract and reports
false.
- Historical action records keep their policy lease and tenant/resource
reason codes decodable, labelled as retired modes.
- The Patrol inbox no longer splits issues into "continuing without a
decision"; every current issue is an operator decision.
- Release gate RG-06 now proves Patrol never executes without an operator
decision (integration tier) instead of limited unattended autonomy,
and RG-02/RG-04 point at the surviving human-admission proofs.
- Pro plan copy, AI docs, privacy telemetry wording and the subsystem
contracts describe the two modes.
The first beta's release workflow failed in create_release at "Locate
existing release". That step reads up to 100 releases with every asset,
about 25 MB, in one call, and GitHub answered it with an HTTP 504. The
step has no pipefail, so the failed read reached jq as empty input and
the job ended with exit code 5. Timing the call from a workstation, one
of three tries returned an error body, so this is not rare.
Retry the read up to five times with the same backoff the asset upload
uses, and accept only a complete listing of valid pages. A failed or
truncated read must never look like "no existing release": that answer
would stage a duplicate draft for a tag that already has one. Exhausting
the attempts fails the job with an explicit error. The listing call and
the downstream handling of an existing draft are unchanged.
Run the real step script in the release policy test against doubles for
gh and sleep: two 504s then a complete listing finds the draft after
backoff of 15s and 30s; a read that exits 0 but is truncated every time
fails after five attempts, with the capped backoff and no outputs; and a
complete listing without the tag still means no existing release. Against
the previous step the test fails with the production symptom, exit 5 and
the 504 message. The create-release pin list and the contract record the
retry.
Contract-Neutral: Release workflow reliability only; no published artifact, tag, signing, install or customer contract changes.
The retained validation ended with an empty model record, not a product erasure verdict. Use atomic replacement for closed model updates so command interruption cannot truncate the state used to judge actual recovery files; production deadlines and safety assertions are unchanged.
Contract-Neutral: Closed fixture observation writes only; no product runtime or contract change.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Compose upstream bed5052eb5 without replacing reviewed history. Keep the accepted one complete stdout/stderr observation and blank-line refusal instead of upstream second-sample replacement. Retain upstream real-systemctl fresh-host assertions and its platform-availability decorator alongside every reviewed failure-retention control. No release, installed recovery or LXC stop-cause claim.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
An owned activation link may already be disabled before a later observation fails; assert exact service/PID/credential retention without re-enabling it. Require the old installed-script PID-erasure adverse control, keeping that runtime observation distinct from credential erasure and new renderer behaviour.
Contract-Neutral: Verification and precise contract documentation only; the production installer is unchanged.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The renderer contains nested functions inside its heredoc; extracting at the first closing brace never exercises its stop function. Bind its full top-level body and inject missing sysrc in the executable model reached by timeout.
Contract-Neutral: Confined test extraction and missing-tool modelling only; no installer or contract behaviour changes.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
The first beta (v6.6.0-beta.1) now passes its preparation checks and
both source pairs, and its release workflow failed twice at the
install.sh smoke test: on a clean Debian 12 container install.sh stops
with "Cannot identify the Pulse systemd service: unit inventory failed".
That is a real regression on main, not a flake. v6.5.0 does not have it,
so no release carries it.
Cause: the 2026-10-10 service discovery change reads `systemctl
list-unit-files -- pulse-backend.service pulse.service` and refuses on
any non-zero exit. systemd exits 1, printing nothing on stdout or
stderr, when none of the named unit files exist, which is every fresh
host (checked on systemd 255 here and by the smoke container's systemd
252). The change's comment says a successful empty read permits a new
installation, but an empty read is not exit 0.
Why the tests missed it: their systemctl double reports no units as exit
0, and `test_partial_failed_inventory_is_not_absence` asserted that an
empty inventory with exit 1 is refused.
Fix: one shared inventory read, used by the installer, the unattended
updater and the auto-update mask check (which had the same hazard). It
accepts exactly the silent exit 1 as an empty inventory, after a second
read confirms there is still no output and no message. A timeout, a
signal, any other status, or an exit 1 that carries output or a message
stays a failed inventory, so real failures still refuse.
Tests: the doubles now model systemd (a failure prints its message, a
silent exit 1 is absence), the two tests that encoded the defect model a
real failure, and new tests cover a fresh host for both scripts,
including real `systemctl --root` over an empty unit root. Contract doc
updated. The registered runtime proofs for install.sh and the unattended
updater (the Go tests that drive this suite) now require the fresh-host
controls to have run and passed.
Checked on pulse-dev: against the unfixed scripts the four new
fresh-host tests fail and the rest pass; against this change all 18
discovery tests, the 2 repair tests and the 16 timer tests pass, and the
Go installer tests pass (184 s).
This replaces #2855, whose first commit lacked the registered proof
files the completion guard requires per commit.
Refs #2785
Compose current main e2f4bdff03 additively. Retain both subsystem records and the held change-age control while withdrawing only the obsolete Discovery identification test. Reviewed identities and ancestry, canonical guest History ownership and upstream feature removal remain intact.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Retain recovery before unknown or unavailable timeout/sysrc observations, require bounded PID records, and align the existing daemon-supervisor assertion with checked signal delivery rather than ignored errors. Every source control remains mandatory.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
Continue #1099: stop and disable the actual legacy manager before remote deregistration or local erasure, recheck after confirmation, and retain PID/service/credential material on refusal or unknown state. Check collector and supervisor absence, exact runlevel ownership and rendered signal failures with confined production-function controls. Appliance bootstrap and native acceptance remain separate.
Change-source: pulse-maintainer
rcourtman