rustfs/docs/architecture/minio-file-format-compat.md

MinIO File-Format Interoperability — Gap Analysis & Phased Plan

Assesses how closely the RustFS on-disk format matches MinIO's, so that a MinIO drive set can be read (and eventually served) by RustFS and vice versa. This is a plan and analysis document. It changes no storage code. Every claim below cites the code that backs it.

Scope: the two on-disk artifacts that matter for interop are the per-object xl.meta (object metadata + inline data) and the per-bucket .metadata.bin (bucket configuration blob). IAM/config layout is noted where it affects bucket-metadata migration.

Refs rustfs/backlog#580.

Executive Summary

• xl.meta: RustFS writes XL_META_VERSION = 3 and reads meta_ver ≤ 3, including legacy meta_ver 2 objects with legacy checksums. Magic XL2 , erasure algorithm rs-vandermonde (Reed-Solomon), and HighwayHash256 bitrot all match MinIO. xl.meta interop is the strong part of the story.
• .metadata.bin: RustFS uses the same filename, the same 4-byte format|version header, the same MessagePack blob layout, and the same per-config field encodings (XML/JSON) as MinIO's bucketMetadata. The divergence is a small set of RustFS-only fields (table-bucket support, bucket-targets meta) — not a format mismatch.
• Migration: RustFS already ships a one-way importer that reads a legacy meta bucket and rewrites bucket-metadata + IAM config into the RustFS meta bucket (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/migration.rs).
• Server-side encryption: not covered by the above. Objects MinIO wrote with SSE-S3, SSE-KMS, or SSE-C are not readable by RustFS in any shipped build. See Part C before planning a migration that includes encrypted objects.

For unencrypted objects the remaining work is verification breadth and closing per-config parsing gaps, not a format rewrite. Encrypted objects are a separate, unsolved axis (rustfs/backlog#1638).

---

Part A — xl.meta Object Format

Version support

Aspect	Value	Evidence
Write version (meta_ver)	3	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:54 (XL_META_VERSION = 3), written in FileMeta::new at crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:121
Read versions accepted	≤ 3 (1, 2, 3)	Decode rejects only meta_ver > XL_META_VERSION — see crates/filemeta/src/filemeta/codec.rs (decode_xl_headers); load_or_convert doc at crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:864
Legacy meta_ver 2 read	Supported (with legacy checksum)	Regression fixtures test_issue_2265_legacy_meta_v2_object_compatibility / test_issue_2288_legacy_xlmeta_compatibility at crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:1130, :1152; uses_legacy_checksum asserted at :1174

RustFS is a read-forward-compatible consumer of MinIO's xl.meta: it can parse older MinIO objects and normalizes them to meta_ver 3 on rewrite. It does not write MinIO's older versions.

Container header

Field	RustFS value	Evidence
Magic	XL2 ([b'X', b'L', b'2', b' '])	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:46
File version major / minor	1 / 3	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:51-52
Header version	3	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:53
Magic + version check (decode entry)	check_xl2_v1 validates magic and rejects major > 1	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta/codec.rs:45-61
Version-only probe (no full parse)	read_format_versions returns (major, minor, header_ver, meta_ver)	crates/filemeta/src/filemeta/codec.rs:30-43

The layout after the 8-byte header is bin-length-prefixed msgpack header block followed by a CRC trailer and optional inline data — matching MinIO's XL2 v1 container.

Erasure coding

Aspect	Value	Evidence
Algorithm enum	ErasureAlgo::ReedSolomon = 1	crates/filemeta/src/fileinfo.rs:83-106
Algorithm string	rs-vandermonde	crates/filemeta/src/fileinfo.rs:31 (ERASURE_ALGORITHM); also crates/ecstore/src/object_api/mod.rs:52
Codec crate	rustfs-erasure-codec (Reed-Solomon, SIMD)	Cargo.toml:277

Same Reed-Solomon Vandermonde scheme and identifier string as MinIO.

Bitrot / shard integrity

Aspect	Value	Evidence
Default hash	HashAlgorithm::HighwayHash256S	Bitrot read/write paths in crates/ecstore/src/io_support/bitrot.rs (e.g. :564, :767)
Legacy variant	HighwayHash256SLegacy (fixed key) for old objects	referenced from rustfs_utils::HashAlgorithm (imported at crates/ecstore/src/io_support/bitrot.rs:26)
HighwayHash crate	highway 1.3.0	Cargo.toml:252
Legacy bitrot read coverage	dedicated test	crates/ecstore/tests/legacy_bitrot_read_test.rs

MinIO uses HighwayHash256 for bitrot; RustFS's default HighwayHash256S is compatible, with a legacy-key variant retained for older shards.

Inline data

Small objects are inlined into the xl.meta container after the CRC trailer rather than written as a separate part.1. Handling lives in crates/filemeta/src/filemeta/inline_data.rs (e.g. physical_data_dir and the shared-data-dir accounting), and the inline block is appended/consumed by the codec in crates/filemeta/src/filemeta/codec.rs. This mirrors MinIO's inline data feature and the null/version-id keying used for the inline map (data_key_for_version at crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs:69, legacy key at :77).

xl.meta interop verdict

Item	Done	Partial	Todo
Read MinIO meta_ver ≤ 3	✅
Legacy meta_ver 2 + legacy checksum read	✅
XL2 container magic/version parity	✅
Reed-Solomon rs-vandermonde parity	✅
HighwayHash256 bitrot parity	✅
Inline data parity	✅
Broad fixture corpus from real MinIO writers		⚠️
Write-back parity for round-trip (RustFS→MinIO read)		⚠️

The two ⚠️ items are verification breadth, not known incompatibilities: the current fixtures are targeted regressions (issues #2265, #2288), and there is no CI job proving a MinIO binary can re-read a RustFS-written xl.meta.

---

Part B — Bucket Metadata (.metadata.bin)

On-disk layout

Aspect	RustFS value	Evidence
Meta bucket	.rustfs.sys	crates/ecstore/src/disk/mod.rs:29 (RUSTFS_META_BUCKET)
Bucket-config prefix	buckets	crates/ecstore/src/disk/mod.rs:34 (BUCKET_META_PREFIX)
Blob file	.metadata.bin	crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs:227 (BUCKET_METADATA_FILE)
Full path	buckets/{bucket}/.metadata.bin	crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs:415-416 (save_file_path)
Header	format: u16 LE + version: u16 LE, both = 1	crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs:228-229, checked in check_header at :595-614
Body	MessagePack-encoded BucketMetadata	marshal_msg/unmarshal at crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs:582-593; read strips the 4-byte header (unmarshal(&data[4..]) at :1079)

This is the same design as MinIO's bucket metadata: a single .minio.sys/buckets/<bucket>/.metadata.bin blob with a 4-byte bucketMetadataFormat|bucketMetadataVersion header and a msgpack body. The filename, header shape, and format/version values (1/1) all match. The BucketMetadata field names correspond one-to-one to MinIO's bucketMetadata struct (policyConfigJSON, lifecycleConfigXML, objectLockConfigXML, …).

Correction to a common misconception: modern MinIO does not store each bucket config as a separate loose versioning.json / lifecycle.json file — it embeds them in the same .metadata.bin blob, with XML for the S3-XML configs and JSON for policy/quota/targets. The per-config filename constants in RustFS (policy.json, lifecycle.xml, …) are the keys used by update_config to select a field, not separate on-disk files.

Interop matrix (backlog#580 items)

Field/constant references are in crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs. "Encoding" is the payload RustFS stores in that field and must match MinIO's for byte-level interop. Getter functions live in crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata_sys.rs.

Config item	RustFS field / constant	Encoding	MinIO field	Status
versioning	versioning_config_xml / BUCKET_VERSIONING_CONFIG = versioning.xml	XML	versioningConfigXML	Done
quota	quota_config_json / BUCKET_QUOTA_CONFIG_FILE = quota.json	JSON	quotaConfigJSON	Done
object_lock	object_lock_config_xml / OBJECT_LOCK_CONFIG = object-lock.xml	XML	objectLockConfigXML	Done
replication	replication_config_xml / BUCKET_REPLICATION_CONFIG = replication.xml	XML	replicationConfigXML	Done
policy	policy_config_json / BUCKET_POLICY_CONFIG = policy.json	JSON	policyConfigJSON	Done
lifecycle	lifecycle_config_xml / BUCKET_LIFECYCLE_CONFIG = lifecycle.xml	XML	lifecycleConfigXML	Done
tagging	tagging_config_xml / BUCKET_TAGGING_CONFIG = tagging.xml	XML	taggingConfigXML	Done
bucket_targets	bucket_targets_config_json + bucket_targets_config_meta_json / BUCKET_TARGETS_FILE = bucket-targets.json	JSON	bucketTargetsConfigJSON (+ meta variant)	Partial
notification	notification_config_xml / BUCKET_NOTIFICATION_CONFIG = notification.xml	XML	notificationConfigXML	Done
encryption	encryption_config_xml / BUCKET_SSECONFIG = bucket-encryption.xml	XML	encryptionConfigXML	Done
cors	cors_config_xml / BUCKET_CORS_CONFIG = cors.xml	XML	corsConfigXML	Done
public_access	public_access_block_config_xml / BUCKET_PUBLIC_ACCESS_BLOCK_CONFIG = public-access-block.xml	XML	publicAccessBlockConfigXML	Done
bucket_acl	bucket_acl_config_json / BUCKET_ACL_CONFIG = bucket-acl.json	JSON	bucketACLConfigJSON	Partial

Field definitions: crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs:274-336. Constants: :227-247. update_config field routing: :678-761. parse_all_configs is invoked on load (load_bucket_metadata_parse at :1043).

Notes on the two "Partial" rows:

• bucket_targets — RustFS carries an extra bucket_targets_config_meta_json field (:288) beyond MinIO's single targets blob. The primary bucket-targets.json payload is interoperable; the meta side-channel is RustFS-specific and a MinIO reader would ignore it. ACL enforcement itself is bounded (S3 PutBucketAcl/PutObjectAcl accept canned ACLs only — see minio-rustfs-router-compatibility.md).
• bucket_acl — stored and round-tripped in the blob, but ACL grant semantics are intentionally limited at the S3 layer.

RustFS also defines fields with no interop requirement from backlog#580 but worth noting so a migration tool does not choke on them: logging_config_xml, website_config_xml, accelerate_config_xml, request_payment_config_xml (:242-245), and the RustFS-only table_bucket_config_json (BUCKET_TABLE_CONFIG = table-bucket.json, :248). A MinIO reader that does not know table_bucket_config_json will ignore the unknown msgpack field.

Old-RustFS → new-RustFS migration

RustFS ships a one-way importer that reads a legacy meta bucket (MIGRATING_META_BUCKET) and rewrites both bucket metadata and IAM config into the current RustFS meta bucket, skipping entries that already exist (idempotent). See crates/ecstore/src/bucket/migration.rs:

• try_migrate_bucket_metadata copies buckets/{bucket}/.metadata.bin and the replication resync blob for each bucket (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/migration.rs:193).
• try_migrate_iam_config walks config/iam/ and normalizes legacy IAM records — legacy timestamp fields (update_at → updatedAt) and legacy policy-mapping field aliases (policies → policy) are rewritten (normalize_iam_config_blob at :97; regression test at :428).
• Bucket resync metadata is re-encoded through ReplicationMigrationBridge (normalize_bucket_meta_blob at :178).

This importer is the practical basis for a MinIO → RustFS bucket-metadata migration: because the blob layout and field encodings already match, the missing piece is a source adapter that points the importer at a MinIO .minio.sys layout rather than the RustFS legacy layout.

Bucket-metadata interop verdict

Item	Done	Partial	Todo
.metadata.bin filename + header + msgpack layout parity	✅
Per-config field encodings (XML/JSON) match MinIO	✅
versioning/quota/object_lock/replication/policy/lifecycle/tagging/notification/encryption/cors/public_access round-trip	✅
bucket_targets primary blob	✅
bucket_targets meta side-channel + ACL grant semantics		⚠️
Old-RustFS → new-RustFS importer	✅
MinIO .minio.sys source adapter for the importer			❌
CI proof a MinIO-written .metadata.bin loads unchanged			❌

---

Part C — Server-Side Encryption (SSE)

Container-format parity does not extend to encrypted object payloads. RustFS currently does not support reading objects that MinIO wrote with server-side encryption — SSE-S3, SSE-KMS, or SSE-C. This is true of every released binary and container image. Tracked in rustfs/backlog#1638.

Note the asymmetry with Parts A and B: the xl.meta around a MinIO SSE object parses fine, so such objects list, HEAD, and report plausible sizes. Only the payload is unreadable.

What can and cannot be migrated

Object class	Readable after moving the drives / copying via S3	Notes
Unencrypted objects	✅	Parts A and B apply.
Bucket metadata, IAM config	✅	Via the importer, once a .minio.sys source adapter exists (see Part B).
Bucket-level default-encryption configuration	✅	The encryption config blob round-trips as a blob; it does not make existing ciphertext readable.
MinIO-written SSE-S3 objects	❌	Seams 1 and 2 below.
MinIO-written SSE-KMS objects	❌	Seams 1 and 2 below.
MinIO-written SSE-C objects	❌	Seam 3 below.
RustFS-written SSE objects read back by MinIO	❌	See "Reverse direction".

Where the read path stops

The primitives match — RustFS implements the same DARE V2 stream format and the same object-key derivation and sealing, and a MinIO sealed-key parser exists (parse_minio_managed_sealed_key, rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:3195). Three seams above the cryptography still reject MinIO-written objects.

#	Seam	Evidence
1	The managed-SSE (SSE-S3 / SSE-KMS) read path returns "not encrypted" unless the object's persisted metadata carries the S3 response key x-amz-server-side-encryption. RustFS writes that key into metadata on PUT; MinIO's internal sealed-key headers alone do not satisfy the gate.	Gate: rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:2432. RustFS write side: rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:391-400.
2	MinIO's wrapped-DEK blob ({"aead": ...}) is neither produced nor accepted. is_data_key_envelope classifies that shape as not a RustFS envelope, and LocalSseDekEnvelope is deny_unknown_fields.	crates/kms/src/encryption/dek.rs:425, :443; rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:2784-2790. Already documented for the static backend at crates/kms/src/config.rs:304-308.
3	SSE-C detection keys on x-amz-server-side-encryption-customer-algorithm, and contains_managed_encryption_metadata omits MinIO's SSE-C sealed-key header, so a MinIO SSE-C object matches neither detection branch. The unsealing code it would need is already written.	Detection: rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:2059 and :3178-3184; the omitted constant is rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:124. Unsealing: rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:2236-2245.

How it fails

The read fails closed: ciphertext is never served as plaintext. Seams 1 and 3 return Ok(None), but that value does not reach the data path. is_object_encryption_marker matches the whole x-minio-internal-server-side-encryption- prefix (crates/utils/src/http/header_compat.rs:50-67), so ObjectInfo::is_encrypted() is true for these objects, and crates/ecstore/src/object_api/readers.rs:559-568 turns the Ok(None) into encrypted object metadata is incomplete while constructing the reader. GET, CopyObject, replication and multipart sources all build the reader through that path. The inline fast path and the body cache both exclude encrypted objects explicitly, so neither bypasses it.

What migrates badly is the diagnosis, not the data. That error is not recognised by map_get_object_reader_error (rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:667), so it surfaces as a 500 InternalError — which reads as a RustFS fault rather than "this object was encrypted by another implementation". List and HEAD still succeed, because xl.meta itself parses normally, so the object looks healthy until something reads it.

Seam 2 surfaces its own error, but only for objects that got past seam 1.

The rio-v2 feature does not change this

rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs contains MinIO-interop code behind #[cfg(feature = "rio-v2")], which can give the impression that enabling the feature closes the gap. It does not, for two independent reasons.

• The feature is not compiled into anything that ships. rio-v2 is absent from both default and full in rustfs/Cargo.toml:39, :48, :51; release binaries are built with no --features flag, and the published images install that binary rather than compiling their own.
• Seam 1 is not feature-gated and runs before the MinIO parser is consulted (rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:2432 precedes :2458). Even with rio-v2 enabled, a MinIO-written managed-SSE object returns at the gate and never reaches parse_minio_managed_sealed_key.

The interop harness reflects this. The reader tests are #[ignore] (rustfs/src/storage/minio_generated_read_test.rs:244, :250), the workflow that would run them is disabled at the GitHub Actions level and states in its own header that end-to-end MinIO-to-RustFS SSE interop is not implemented (.github/workflows/minio-interop.yml:24-29, :34-39), and the fixture suite's scope note says the tests "do not yet validate full plaintext reconstruction from MinIO-written encrypted data" (crates/rio-v2/tests/README.md:55).

Reverse direction

Migrating back is also unsupported. Under rio-v2 RustFS writes its own DEK envelope into MinIO's sealed-key metadata slots and labels it with MinIO's seal algorithm (rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:1830-1852), so the metadata is MinIO-shaped while the key bytes are not MinIO-openable. Default builds do not populate those slots at all (rustfs/src/storage/sse.rs:1796-1798). Treat RustFS-written SSE objects as readable only by RustFS.

Working around the limitation

Until rustfs/backlog#1638 lands, the options are:

• Decrypt on the MinIO side first: rewrite the affected objects as plaintext (or copy them out through MinIO's S3 endpoint, which decrypts on read) and migrate the plaintext, applying RustFS-side encryption afterwards.
• Copy through the S3 API rather than moving drives: a client that reads from MinIO and writes to RustFS gets plaintext from the source and lets RustFS encrypt with its own KMS. This re-encrypts rather than preserving ciphertext, and costs a full data transfer.
• Leave encrypted objects on MinIO and migrate only unencrypted data.

Inventory the source first — bucket default-encryption settings mean objects can be encrypted without the uploader having asked for it, so "we never set SSE headers" is not sufficient evidence that a bucket has no encrypted objects.

SSE interop verdict

Item	Done	Partial	Todo
DARE V2 stream format parity	✅
Object-key derivation / sealing parity	✅
MinIO sealed-key parser exists (behind rio-v2)		⚠️
Managed-SSE detection accepts MinIO-written metadata			❌
MinIO {"aead": ...} wrapped-DEK parser			❌
SSE-C detection accepts MinIO-written metadata			❌
Read MinIO-written SSE-S3 / SSE-KMS / SSE-C objects end to end			❌
RustFS-written SSE objects readable by MinIO			❌
CI proof of SSE read parity			❌

---

Phased Plan

The format is already close; the plan is verification, a source adapter, and closing the two partial encodings — not a rewrite.

Phase 1 — Read parity, proven (verification)

• Add a MinIO-writer fixture corpus for xl.meta (inline + multipart + versioned + delete-marker + transitioned) and assert RustFS parses each to a FileInfo equivalent to MinIO's, alongside the existing issue #2265 / #2288 fixtures in crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs.
• Add a fixture .metadata.bin written by MinIO and assert BucketMetadata::unmarshal + parse_all_configs load every field without loss (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs).
• Exit criterion: a CI job that fails if a real MinIO-written object or bucket blob cannot be read.

Phase 1 status — first fixtures landed (verified 2026-07-07)

A real MinIO RELEASE.2025-07-23 single-drive instance wrote a bucket with versioning, object-lock (GOVERNANCE default), lifecycle, tagging, quota, and a public-download policy, plus inline / versioned / multipart objects. The on-disk xl.meta blobs are captured as hex fixtures (crates/filemeta/tests/fixtures/minio/, crates/ecstore/tests/fixtures/minio/).

Proven by regression tests:

• Object xl.meta read parity — parses_real_minio_object_xlmeta (crates/filemeta/src/filemeta.rs): small inline, two-object-version + delete marker, and multipart objects all parse to the expected FileInfo.
• Bucket-metadata parse parity — parses_real_minio_bucket_metadata_blob_without_loss (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs): the msgpack blob decodes via the PascalCase MinIO field names, and parse_all_configs loads all ten config types present in the corpus without loss — policy, lifecycle (including MinIO's <ExpiryUpdatedAt> extension), object-lock, versioning, tagging, quota, notification, encryption (SSE-S3), and replication (including the DeleteMarkerReplication / ExistingObjectReplication MinIO extensions).
• Inline bucket-metadata read parity — reads_minio_inline_bucket_metadata_via_bitrot (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/metadata.rs): MinIO stores an inlined object body as [HighwayHash256 (32B)][body]. The "inline_data 前缀不同" that weisd raised on 2026-03-06 is exactly that bitrot prefix — not a format incompatibility. Feeding the raw inline shard through RustFS's BitrotReader with the default HighwayHash256S verifies the checksum (confirming RustFS's hash matches MinIO's) and yields the exact .metadata.bin blob, which then parses. So the object-layer inline read is compatible; the earlier "extract fi.data directly" concern was reading the shard before the bitrot layer strips its prefix.
• End-to-end migration — migrates_real_minio_bucket_metadata_end_to_end (crates/ecstore/src/bucket/migration.rs): on a throwaway 4-drive local ECStore, a real MinIO .metadata.bin seeded under a .minio.sys layout is migrated by try_migrate_bucket_metadata into .rustfs.sys, and the migrated blob carries every config (policy / lifecycle / object-lock / versioning / tagging / quota / notification / encryption / replication) byte-identical to the source. This exercises the Phase 2 source adapter (MIGRATING_META_BUCKET = ".minio.sys") end-to-end through the object layer — proven, not just present.

Still to broaden: transitioned xl.meta; CORS, public-access-block, and bucket ACL configs (the SNSD test binary/mc did not expose these); and bucket-targets credentials, which MinIO stores KMS-encrypted (a documented partial). These run as ordinary crate tests, so they already execute in the normal cargo test/nextest CI jobs.

Phase 2 — MinIO source adapter for migration

• Generalize the importer in crates/ecstore/src/bucket/migration.rs so the source can be a MinIO .minio.sys/buckets/<bucket>/.metadata.bin layout, not only the RustFS legacy meta bucket. Because the blob format matches, this is mostly source-path plumbing plus IAM record normalization reuse.
• Exit criterion: importing a MinIO backup reproduces all backlog#580 bucket-config items with byte-identical config payloads.

Phase 3 — Close the two partial encodings

• bucket_targets: document/normalize the RustFS-only bucket_targets_config_meta_json so a round-trip through MinIO and back does not silently drop it; or fold its content into a MinIO-compatible representation.
• bucket_acl: decide whether ACL grant semantics beyond canned ACLs are in scope; if not, keep the blob round-trippable but document the enforcement limit (already reflected in the router compatibility matrix).

Phase 4 — Round-trip / write-back parity (non-goal for migration)

Proving a MinIO binary can re-read a RustFS-written drive set (the reverse direction) is out of scope for the migration use case, which is one-way MinIO → RustFS:

• RustFS's meta bucket is .rustfs.sys (crates/ecstore/src/disk/mod.rs:29); MinIO looks for .minio.sys. A MinIO binary pointed at a RustFS drive set does not find format.json or bucket configs and refuses the set — this is a set-level divergence, not an object-format one.
• The object-level xl.meta format does match (proven above), so the reverse direction is limited by drive-set discovery, not by per-object encoding.
• The supported flow is one-way: try_migrate_bucket_metadata / try_migrate_iam_config / format.json migration import a MinIO layout into RustFS. There is no requirement to keep a live MinIO able to serve RustFS-written drives.

If a true bidirectional round-trip is ever needed, it would require RustFS to optionally write the .minio.sys set layout — a separate feature, not part of the interop/migration story tracked here.

---

Guardrails

• This document is analysis only. Any change to crates/filemeta or crates/ecstore/src/bucket metadata encoding is a storage-format change and must follow the migration and readiness contracts in README.md and the ecstore layout boundary rules.
• The version constants (XL_META_VERSION, BUCKET_METADATA_FORMAT/BUCKET_METADATA_VERSION) are compatibility anchors. Bumping any of them requires a read-compat path for the prior value and a migration story, exactly as the current meta_ver 2 → 3 read path provides.