Simplify source serialization and validation logic while improving
type safety around room configuration handling.
Introduce a dedicated TypeScript type matching the backend
Pydantic model more precisely.
Also harmonize track source casing between frontend and backend to
remove redundant conversion logic and resolve#1282.
Introduce synchronization of room configuration changes across
active participants.
When a room configuration is updated through a PUT operation, the
backend now performs an additional LiveKit API call to notify room
participants through a room metadata update event.
This ensures admins and owners quickly see up-to-date settings in
their administration panel. It also prepares the frontend for
automatic updates of unprivileged participants room’s data without
refetching it from the API.
An event-driven design was chosen instead of storing the full room
configuration in LiveKit metadata. While embedding the state
directly in metadata would provide immediate synchronization, it
would also require initializing and maintaining configuration
state during room creation or webhook handling, increasing the
risk of operational failures and regressions.
Instead, the backend emits lightweight synchronization events and
active clients update their React Query cache, which remains the
single source of truth for room configuration data.
Introduce a new room setting controlling whether all participants,
including non-privileged users, can mute others.
Update API validation accordingly and add the frontend controls
allowing administrators to toggle the option and persist the
configuration through the API.
Enable any participant to mute others when the room configuration
allows it. This is enabled by default for all meetings unless
explicitly disabled by an administrator.
Privileged users retain the ability to mute any participant
regardless of the room configuration.
Wrap Recording and RecordingAccess creation in a single transaction so a
partial failure does not leave orphan rows, and return 409 instead of 500
when a recording is already in progress for the room.
When the worker fails to start, transition the Recording to
FAILED_TO_START so the unique partial constraint on (room, status) no
longer blocks future recording attempts on the same room.
Room.configuration accepted arbitrary JSON without validation, allowing unsafe
or malformed payloads to be stored and creating a security risk. Define a
Pydantic schema to enforce structure and constraints, and add validation
at the serializer level to reject invalid inputs.
Introduce MetadataCollector and MetadataCollectorService classes to
centralize the collection and storage of user connections, VAD events,
and chat messages. This creates a structured foundation for future speaker
assignment logic based on voice activity detection. Add tests for this new
feature.
Tests were incorrectly mocking Twirp errors using HTTP status
codes instead of the meaningful error codes returned by the
LiveKit SDK.
Update mocks to reflect actual SDK behavior.
Replace passing the LiveKit JWT in the request body with the
Authorization header, following standard authentication practices.
Extend the LiveKit authentication backend usage across additional
endpoints.
This also raises questions about how clients should securely
retrieve LiveKit tokens, to be addressed later.
Avoid mapping all Twirp errors to generic 500 responses.
Explicitly handle the case where a participant is no longer in
the room, as this may indicate suspicious behavior or a client
state issue.
Improve error discrimination to provide more accurate responses.
Introduce toggle-hand and rename endpoints in RoomViewSet,
secured with LiveKit token authentication.
Remove direct permission for clients to update their own metadata
via LiveKit tokens to prevent spoofing (e.g. faking admin status).
Proxy participant metadata updates through the backend to enforce
proper validation and authorization.
Signed-off-by: lebaudantoine <lebaud.antoine131@gmail.com>
Resolve warnings raised in jwt/api_jwt.py:365 by ensuring test
keys meet the required security length.
Align test configuration with expected cryptographic standards.
Serialization hardening introduced a breaking change between the
frontend and backend. Adjust the Pydantic model to restore
compatibility.
Reinstate support for can_subscribe_metric, which is passed by
default from the frontend.
Prevent invited participants from seeing each other's email
addresses when sending room invitations.
Ensure invitations are sent with proper isolation to avoid
mass PII disclosure.
This mitigates risks of email harvesting, spam, and phishing
through the platform.
Sanitize error handling to prevent leaking internal details when
invalid or malicious requests are sent to the API.
Return generic error responses to reduce the risk of information
disclosure during probing attempts.
Improve validation of parameters accepted when starting a
recording to prevent unsupported or unexpected values.
Language validation will be further tightened to only accept
languages supported by the transcribe microservice.
Add extensive API validation tests to cover these scenarios.
During the bug bounty, attempts were made to pass unexpected hidden
fields to manipulate room behavior and join as a ghost.
Treat these parameters as suspicious. They are not sent by the
frontend, so their presence likely indicates tampering.
Explicitly allow the parameters but emit warning logs to help detect
and investigate suspicious activity.
Refactor feature flag mechanism from Django permission classes to custom
decorator that returns 404 Not Found when features are disabled instead
of exposing API structure through permission errors.
Improves security by preventing information disclosure about disabled
features and provides more appropriate response semantics. Custom
decorator approach is better suited for feature toggling than Django's
permission system which is designed for authorization.
Refactor client-side LiveKit API calls to server-side endpoints
following LiveKit documentation recommendations for participant
management operations.
Replaces hacky direct client calls with proper backend-mediated
requests, improving security and following official LiveKit
Refactor lobby system to use consistent UUID v4 across lobby
registration and LiveKit token participant identity instead of
generating separate UUIDs.
Maintains synchronized identifiers between lobby cache and LiveKit
participants, simplifying future participant removal operations by
using the same UUID reference across both systems.
Extend LiveKit token creation utility with additional room configuration
and user role parameters to properly adapt room_admin grants and
publish sources based on permission levels.
This creates technical debt in utility function design that should be
refactored into proper service architecture for token
generation operations in future iterations.
Allow any user, anonymous or authenticated, to start subtitling
in a room only if they are an active participant of it.
Subtitling a room consists of starting the multi-user transcriber agent.
This agent forwards all participants' audio to an STT server and returns
transcription segments for any active voice to the room.
User roles in the backend room system cannot be used
to determine subtitle permissions.
The transcriber agent can be triggered multiple times but will only join a
room once. Unicity is managed by the agent itself.
Any user with a valid LiveKit token can initiate subtitles. Feature flag
logic is implemented on the frontend. The frontend ensures the "start
subtitle" action is only available to users who should see it. The backend
does not enforce feature flags in this version.
Authentication in our system does not imply access to a room. The only
valid proof of access is the LiveKit API token issued by the backend.
Security consideration: A LiveKit API token is valid for 6 hours and
cannot be revoked at the end of a meeting. It is important to verify
that the token was issued for the correct room.
Calls to the agent dispatch endpoint must be server-initiated. The backend
proxies these calls, as clients cannot securely contact the agent dispatch
endpoint directly (per LiveKit documentation).
Room ID is passed as a query parameter. There is currently no validation
ensuring that the room exists prior to agent dispatch.
TODO: implement validation or error handling for non-existent rooms.
The backend does not forward LiveKit tokens to the agent. Default API
rate limiting is applied to prevent abuse.
Move from lobby service to utils for reuse across services. Method is
generic enough for utility status. Future: create dedicated LiveKit
service to encapsulate all LiveKit-related utilities.
Implemented a service that automatically creates a SIP dispatch rule when
the first WebRTC participant joins a room and removes it when the room
becomes empty.
Why? I don’t want a SIP participant to join an empty room.
The PIN code could be easily leaked, and there is currently no lobby
mechanism available for SIP participants.
A WebRTC participant is still required to create a room.
This behavior is inspired by a proprietary tool. The service uses LiveKit’s
webhook notification system to react to room lifecycle events. This is
a naive implementation that currently supports only a single SIP trunk and
will require refactoring to support multiple trunks. When no trunk is
specified, rules are created by default on a fallback trunk.
@rouja wrote a minimal Helm chart for LiveKit SIP with Asterisk, which
couldn’t be versioned yet due to embedded credentials. I deployed it
locally and successfully tested the integration with a remote
OVH SIP trunk.
One point to note: LiveKit lacks advanced filtering capabilities when
listing dispatch rules. Their recommendation is to fetch all rules and
filter them within your backend logic. I’ve opened a feature request asking
for at least the ability to filter dispatch rules by room, since filtering
by trunk is already supported, room-based filtering feels like a natural
addition.
Until there's an update, I prefer to keep the implementation simple.
It works well at our current scale, and can be refactored when higher load
or multi-trunk support becomes necessary.
While caching dispatch rule IDs could be a performance optimization,
I feel it would be premature and potentially error-prone due to the complexity
of invalidation. If performance becomes an issue, I’ll consider introducing
caching at that point. To handle the edge case where multiple dispatch rules
with different PIN codes are present, the service performs an extensive
cleanup during room creation to ensure SIP routing remains clean and
predictable. This edge case should not happen.
In the 'delete_dispatch_rule' if deleting one rule fails, method would exit
without deleting the other rules. It's okay IMO for a first iteration.
If multiple dispatch rules are often found for room, I would enhance this part.
Remove assertion statement that was placed after code expected to raise an
exception. The assertion was never evaluated due to the exception flow,
making the test ineffective.
Restrict access to room user permissions data by excluding this information
from room serializer response for non-admin/owner users. Previously all
members could see complete access lists. Change enforces stricter information
access control based on user role.
Spotted in #YWH-PGM14336-5.
Add user language and timezone to serialized user data to enable frontend
customization. Allows backend email notifications to respect user's
localization preferences for improved communication relevance.
Implement new endpoint allowing admin/owner to invite participants via email.
Provides explicit way to search users and send meeting invitations with
direct links.
In upcoming commits, frontend will call ResourceAccess endpoint to add
invited people as members if they exist in visio, bypassing waiting room
for a smoother experience.
Necessary in cross browser context situation, where we need to
pass data of a room newly created between two different windows.
This happens in Calendar integration.
Add new endpoint to access the event-handler matching service. Route is
protected by LiveKit authentication, handle at the service level.
Enables webhook event processing through standardized API.
Introduce new intermediate access level between public and restricted that
allows authenticated users to join rooms without admin approval. Not making
this the default level yet as current 12hr sessions would create painful
user experience for accessing rooms. Will reconsider default settings after
improving session management.
This access level definition may evolve to become stricter in the future,
potentially limiting access to authenticated users who share the same
organization as the room admin.
Implement lobby service using cache as LiveKit doesn't natively support
secure lobby functionality. Their teams recommended to create our own
system in our app's backend.
The lobby system is totally independant of the DRF session IDs,
making the request_entry endpoint authentication agnostic.
This decoupling prevents future DRF changes from breaking lobby functionality
and makes participant tracking more explicit.
Security audit is needed as current LiveKit tokens have excessive privileges
for unprivileged users. I'll offer more option ASAP for the admin to control
participant privileges.
Race condition handling also requires improvements, but should not be critical
at this point.
A great enhancement, would be to add a webhook, notifying the backend when the
room is closed, to reset cache.
This commit makes redis a prerequesite to run the suite of tests. The readme
and CI will be updated in dedicated commits.
Replace unused is_public boolean field with access_level to allow for more
granular control. Initially maintains public/restricted functionality while
enabling future addition of "trusted" access level.
Avoided unnecessary manipulation of the room name to prevent issues when
starting an egress worker. Previously, hyphens were stripped from the room
name, likely inherited from the legacy setup with Jitsi in Magnify, though
the purpose of this change is unclear and might be an undesired legacy
feature.
To ensure accurate room matching during egress worker requests, this update
removes any manipulation of the room name. This approach minimizes the risk
of errors when initiating recordings and maintains the integrity of the
original room name throughout the process.
The LiveKit egress worker interactions are proxied through the backend for
security reasons. Allowing clients to directly use tokens with sufficient
grants to start recordings could lead to misuse, enabling users to spam the
egress worker API and potentially initiate a DDOS attack on the egress
service. To prevent this, only users with room-specific privileges can
initiate recordings.
We make sure only one recording at the time can be made on a room.
The requested recording mode is stored so it can be referenced later when
the recording is saved, triggering a callback action as needed.
A feature flag was also introduced for this capability; while this is a simple
approach, a more robust system for managing feature flags could be valuable
long-term. For now, KISS (Keep It Simple, Stupid) applies.
The viewset endpoints were designed to be as straightforward as possible—
let me know if anything can be improved.
Recent updates of dev/ruff and dev/pylint dependencies led
to new linting warnings.
Pylint 3.2.0 introduced a new check `possibly-used-before-assignment`,
which ensures variables are defined regardless of conditional statements.
Some if/else branches were missing defaults. These have been fixed.
Quick and dirty approach. It works, that's essential.
Frontend can pass a desired username for the user. This would
be the name displayed in the room to other participants.
Usernames don't need to be unique, but user identities do
If no username is passed, API will fall back to a default username.
Why? This serves as a security mechanism. If the API is called
incorrectly by a client, it maintains the previous behavior.
It seems appropriate that backend owns the responsability of knowing any
information/configurations of the LiveKit server. Then, it shares those
with the frontend.
Please see my previous commit to understand why environment variables are
not appropriate for deployment in several remove environments.
As of today, the LiveKit server URL is the only configuration exposed
dynamically to the frontend. Thus, it doesn't justify adding a new route
to the API, responsible for exposing configurations (e.g. /configuration).
As the frontend needs to call the backend when it wants to initiate a new
webconference room, let's pass the server URL when retrieving the room's token.
It is relevant, to get both the room location and the keys to open the room in
the same call.
I prefered to be pragmatic, if the need appears any soon, I would refactor
these parts.
I have updated all references of "Impress" to "Meet".
Migrations were manually updated and not regenerated. Never-mind,
they all will be squashed before the first release.
I have also searched for reference to "Magnify", and replaced them
by "Meet".
While updating the backend sources, I have also fixed other parts of
the project, namely:
- Compose file
- Github documentation and CI
- Makefile commands
lebaudantoine