mirror of
https://github.com/taylanbakircioglu/haproxy-openmanager.git
synced 2026-09-12 05:48:58 +00:00
taylanbakircioglu
7d95c737f0
Four defects found while tracing the adoption flow end to end after v1.10.4
reached a live HA pair.
B3/B4 (one root, one fix). Adoption took only the node whose row was clicked:
- adopting the BACKUP alone produced a VIP that apply always rejects, because
apply requires exactly one MASTER member;
- adopting the MASTER alone left the peer unmanaged, and adopting it
afterwards hit the VRID-collision guard with 409, so a pair could never be
completed from the panel;
- on a UNICAST instance the single-member render dropped the unicast block
entirely (render_keepalived_conf emits it only when peer_ips is non-empty),
so keepalived fell back to multicast on the adopted node while its peer
stayed unicast. They stop seeing each other and BOTH claim the VIP.
Adoption now resolves the whole instance via _collect_instance_participants,
keyed on (virtual_router_id, virtual address) - the same key keepalived uses to
group nodes. Each participant becomes a member with the role, priority and
interface its own file declares, and its own one-shot takeover hash, so the
per-node overwrite guard is unchanged. It refuses, naming the reason, when the
group has other than one MASTER, when advert_int differs across nodes, when a
declared unicast peer is not among the nodes being adopted, or when a node is
already in a live VIP - the one-active-VIP-per-agent rule that create/update
enforce via _validate_members_against_pool and adoption never called.
B1. The Apply Management "View Change" regex matched vip-(create|update|delete)
only, so an adopt version fell through to the generic HAProxy diff and rendered
the cluster's whole haproxy.cfg as removed. Display-only, but alarming. A test
now asserts every action _stage_vip_version can stage is in that alternation.
B2. Rejecting an adoption hid the node from the panel permanently:
vip_discoveries.adopted_vip_id is write-once, a VIP is only ever soft-deleted so
the column's ON DELETE SET NULL never fires, and the agent does not re-report a
file whose hash has not changed. Rather than clearing the column on each path,
adoptability is derived from whether the linked VIP is still active, which
self-heals reject, undo-reject and approved teardown alike.
The panel now lists one row per instance instead of per node, and the adopt
dialog names every node that will be taken over. Blockers are aggregated across
all of them, matching what the endpoint checks.
No schema change, no agent change, no API-shape break: /api/vip/discoveries
gains a derived field and /api/vip/adopt keeps its request body.
Backend suite: 1359 passed, 152 skipped. Frontend build clean (no new lint
warnings in VIPManagement.js).