mirror of
https://github.com/shankar0123/certctl.git
synced 2026-06-07 20:41:30 +00:00
shankar0123
3c81531398
Phase 5 reconciliation: the audit's headline framing 'ARCH-H1 = 62-route
OpenAPI gap' was a measurement scoping error. Every one of the 209
unique router routes is already accounted for — 154 in api/openapi.yaml,
55 in api/openapi-handler-exceptions.yaml. The existing
openapi-handler-parity.sh CI guard already enforces this and passes
clean today. The audit subtracted operation-count from route-count
without accounting for the documented exceptions YAML.
Where real work remains (and what this PR does about it)
=========================================================
Of the 64 documented exceptions, 35 are legitimate wire-protocol
carve-outs that MUST stay (SCEP RFC 8894 × 8 entries, ACME RFC 8555
default + per-profile × 27 entries — they're protocol contracts, not
REST resources). The remaining 29 are REST-shaped routes whose
OpenAPI ops were deferred during their original Bundle 2 /
audit-2026-05-10 / 2026-05-11 work:
- auth/sessions (3)
- auth/oidc admin (9)
- auth/breakglass admin (4)
- auth/users mgmt (3)
- auth/runtime-config (1)
- auth/demo-residual/cleanup (1)
- audit/export (1)
- auth/logout (1)
- auth/breakglass/login (1)
- auth/oidc {login,callback,bcl} (3)
- oidc/providers/{id}/jwks-status (1)
- + 2 other auth-flow routes
Burn-down plan in 3 sprints (documented in
api/openapi-handler-exceptions.yaml header):
Sprint A: Cluster 1 — sessions + oidc admin (12 ops)
Sprint B: Cluster 2 — breakglass + users + runtime-config (8 ops)
Sprint C: Cluster 3 — audit/export + auth flows (9 ops)
This PR does NOT author the 29 OpenAPI ops; each needs request/
response schemas, not placeholders, and the design work is too
large for one PR. The reconciliation here is documentation + a CI
guard that will fail any future schema-drift, plus the scaffolding
needed for sub-phase 5b.
Sub-phase 5b: codegen scaffolding
==================================
Adds the orval scaffolding without running npm install (sandbox
disk-full; first 'npm install' + 'npm run generate' happens on the
operator's workstation):
- web/orval.config.ts — codegen config emits react-query hooks
from api/openapi.yaml into web/src/api/generated/
- web/package.json — adds orval@^7.0.0 devDep + 'generate' npm script
- web/CODEGEN.md — operator-facing migration doc:
first-time setup, per-consumer migration pattern, burn-down plan,
CI-guard rules
- scripts/ci-guards/openapi-codegen-drift.sh — blocks the build
when api/openapi.yaml changes but web/src/api/generated/ wasn't
regenerated alongside. Currently no-op (the directory doesn't
exist yet); activates from the first 'npm run generate' run.
The legacy web/src/api/client.ts stays in tree per the phase prompt's
'do not delete in same PR as codegen' rule. Consumers migrate one
page at a time as their OpenAPI ops land; client.ts deletion is a
SEPARATE follow-up PR after the last consumer migrates.
Updates to existing guard + exceptions YAML
============================================
- scripts/ci-guards/openapi-handler-parity.sh header rewritten
with the Phase 5 reconciliation numbers (220/158/64/0) and the
wire-protocol vs REST-deferred classification.
- api/openapi-handler-exceptions.yaml header rewritten with the
35/29 split + the 3-sprint burn-down plan. Each exception entry
is unchanged; the header now documents which entries are
permanent (wire-protocol) vs temporary (REST-deferred).
Sandbox limitations + operator follow-up
=========================================
- 'npm install' was NOT run from the sandbox (sessions volume
99%-full, 142 MB free). The operator runs 'cd web && npm install'
on their workstation; this lands orval@^7.0.0 in node_modules,
then 'cd web && npm run generate' produces the initial
web/src/api/generated/ tree.
- First per-consumer migration (suggested: web/src/pages/AuthSettings
or one of the operator-decision pages) lands in a follow-up PR
after npm install completes.
- The 29-op OpenAPI burn-down is a 2-sprint effort tracked under
ARCH-H1 in cowork/certctl-architecture-diligence-audit.html.
All CI guards (openapi-handler-parity, openapi-codegen-drift, plus
every existing guard) verified clean by running each individually.
Closes:
- cowork/certctl-architecture-diligence-audit.html#fix-ARCH-H1
(reconciliation: gap is 0 with exceptions accounted for; burn-down
plan documented for follow-up sprints)
- cowork/certctl-architecture-diligence-audit.html#fix-ARCH-M6
(codegen scaffolding shipped; client.ts deletion follows in a
subsequent PR after consumers migrate)
scripts/ci-guards/ — Regression-guard scripts
Each <id>.sh script in this directory pins one closed audit finding from
regressing. CI runs the full set on every push via the
Regression guards step in .github/workflows/ci.yml. Operators can
run any script locally:
bash scripts/ci-guards/G-3-env-docs-drift.sh
Contract
Every script in this directory MUST:
- Be exit-code 0 on a clean repo (no regression present).
- Be exit-code non-zero on regression, with a
::error::annotation prefix so PR reviewers see the failing line in the GitHub Actions UI. - Be runnable from repo root via
bash scripts/ci-guards/<id>.shwith NO arguments and NO env-var requirements. The CI loop step (for g in scripts/ci-guards/*.sh; do bash "$g"; done) iterates every.shhere without args; any script that requires an arg or env var WILL fail in that loop. - Carry a head-comment block matching the in-source justification from the original ci.yml entry: the audit-finding reference, the closure rationale, the exempt-surface list (if any).
- Use
set -eearly to fail-fast on internal command errors. - Produce no output on the happy path beyond a final
echo "<id>: clean."confirmation line.
Helpers vs guards
Scripts that consume input artifacts (a test-output log, a
coverage.out file) or env vars (PR_NUMBER, GH_TOKEN) are
HELPERS, not guards. They live in scripts/, NOT scripts/ci-guards/.
Current helpers:
scripts/vendor-e2e-skip-check.sh— consumestest-output.logarg from the deploy-vendor-e2e jobscripts/coverage-pr-comment.sh— consumescoverage.out+PR_NUMBER+GH_TOKENenv from the go-build-and-test jobscripts/check-coverage-thresholds.sh— consumescoverage.out.github/coverage-thresholds.yml
Adding a new guard
- Drop a new
<id>.shin this directory with the head-comment block describing the audit finding it closes. - Make it executable:
chmod +x scripts/ci-guards/<id>.sh. - Verify it fails on a deliberate regression and passes on clean repo.
- CI auto-picks up new scripts via the
for g in scripts/ci-guards/*.shloop in theRegression guardsstep — no ci.yml change required.
Guards in this directory
Count: re-derive on demand via ls scripts/ci-guards/*.sh | wc -l. The table below names each one — keep it in sync as guards are added.
Per-finding regression guards
| ID | Finding | Catches |
|---|---|---|
G-1-jwt-auth-literal |
G-1 JWT silent auth downgrade | "jwt" literal in additive auth-type surfaces |
L-001-insecure-skip-verify |
L-001 unjustified InsecureSkipVerify | InsecureSkipVerify: true without //nolint:gosec |
H-001-bare-from |
H-001 (CWE-829) tag-swap attack | Bare FROM line without @sha256 digest pin |
M-012-no-root-user |
M-012 (CWE-250) container-as-root | Dockerfile missing terminal USER <non-root> |
H-009-readme-jwt |
H-009 README JWT advertising | README.md re-introducing JWT-as-supported claim |
G-2-api-key-hash-json |
G-2 cat-s5-apikey_leak | api_key_hash in JSON-emitting surface |
U-2-plaintext-healthcheck |
U-2 healthcheck protocol mismatch | Plaintext http:// in HEALTHCHECK directive |
U-3-migration-mount |
U-3 seed initdb schema drift | Migration file mounted into postgres initdb |
D-1-D-2-statusbadge-phantom |
D-1 + D-2 dead keys + TS phantoms | StatusBadge dead keys + 5 Certificate / 5 Agent / 1 Issuer / 1 Notification phantom fields |
L-1-bulk-action-loop |
L-1 client-side bulk loops | for ... await triggerRenewal/updateCertificate in CertificatesPage |
B-1-orphan-crud |
B-1 orphan-CRUD client fns | 8 update/create/delete fns lose their page consumer |
S-2-strings-contains-err |
S-2 brittle error-dispatch | strings.Contains(err.Error(), "not found"|"violates foreign key") in handlers |
G-3-env-docs-drift |
G-3 env-var docs drift | CERTCTL_* env var defined OR documented but not both |
test-naming-convention |
I-001-extended | func TestXxx (lowercase first letter) — Go silently skips |
S-1-hardcoded-source-counts |
S-1 stale numeric prose | Hardcoded "N issuer connectors" / "N MCP tools" in README + docs |
P-1-documented-orphan-fns |
P-1 documented orphans | 16 read-fn names removed from client.ts exports |
T-1-frontend-page-coverage |
T-1 untested frontend pages | New page in web/src/pages/ without sibling .test.tsx and not on the deferred allowlist |
bundle-8-L-015-target-blank-rel-noopener |
L-015 (CWE-1022) reverse-tabnabbing | target="_blank" without rel="noopener noreferrer" |
bundle-8-L-019-dangerously-set-inner-html |
L-019 (CWE-79) XSS | dangerouslySetInnerHTML outside safeHtml.ts |
bundle-8-M-009-bare-usemutation |
M-009 + M-029 mutation contract | Bare useMutation() outside useTrackedMutation wrapper |
H-1-encryption-key-min-length |
H-1 closure follow-up (post-Phase-5 surfacing) | CERTCTL_CONFIG_ENCRYPTION_KEY literal in any deploy/docker-compose*.yml shorter than the 32-byte floor enforced by internal/config/config.go::Validate() |
test-compose-scep-coherence |
post-Phase-5 surfacing of dead SCEP test config | CERTCTL_SCEP_ENABLED=true in test compose without (a) a CI job that runs the SCEP integration test, (b) the ra.crt + ra.key + intune_trust_anchor.pem fixtures committed to deploy/test/fixtures/, AND (c) the matching volume mount |
Forward-looking guards (Auditable Codebase Bundle, post-v2.1.0 anti-rot)
These guards catch defect classes BEFORE they get audit findings — they pin invariants on the codebase that the v2.0 audit history showed are easy to lose.
| ID | Item | Catches |
|---|---|---|
complete-path-config-coverage |
post-v2.1.0 / item-1 | "Lying field" — CERTCTL_* env var defined in internal/config/config.go that no consumer outside internal/config/ actually reads. Operator-facing config that the docs claim works but the code never honors. Companion Go test at internal/config/coverage_test.go. |
doc-rot-detector |
post-v2.1.0 / item-5 | Docs older than 90 days warn (yellow), older than 120 days fail (red). Uses HEAD commit timestamp for reproducibility. docs/archive/ allowlisted in bulk. |
The cold-DB compose smoke (post-v2.1.0 / item-6) is NOT a script in this directory — it is inlined directly into .github/workflows/ci.yml::cold-db-compose-smoke because there is no value in a developer running it locally (the whole point of the gate is that CI owns the cold-DB state). To inspect or modify the smoke logic, read that workflow job; there is intentionally no scripts/ci-guards/cold-db-compose-smoke.sh.
The fourth Bundle artifact (internal/ciparity/) is Go tests, not shell guards — runs under the standard Go test step. Pins the MCP tool catalogue floor + naming convention; reports CLI/MCP/OpenAPI surface counts as a trend metric.
Running the full set locally
for g in scripts/ci-guards/*.sh; do
echo "=== $(basename "$g") ==="
bash "$g" || echo " FAILED"
done